Information InFiltration. Artivist mediactive techculture - and a whole lot more.

front page???E.A.Dobbsreview-a-rama

secret room upstairsFilterItYourselfwhatever
[- Book Review: Metromarxism by Andy Merrifield
reviews
By TreborScholz, Section review-a-rama
Posted on Tue May 13th, 2003 at 08:04:17 AM EURODISCORDIA TIME
summer reading: Metromarxism by Andy Merrifield

A Marxist Tale of the City
(Routledge, 2002)

From Mr. Marx to Sir Engels to Herrn Benjamin, Monsieur Lefebvre and Debord to David Harvey and Marshall Berman. The author looks at these Marxist scholars and their relationship to the city.

 

[ --------------------------------------------- ]

When Daniel Libeskind designed the windows of the Jewish Museum in Berlin he started with a list of the Jewish intellectuals closest to his heart. He then pinned down their living quarters on a map of Berlin of the time. Now his marker would glide from one dot to the other and the shapes that appeared on paper are now the frames through which visitors to the museum look at the Berlin of today.


In a somewhat similar manner, Andy Merrifield links Marxist theorists, dead or alive, in this charming, and witty book getting the core of their philosophies across and ending each chapter looking at biographical details that become evidence of their particular relationship to the city. Let's grandfather Marx speak:

Now, humans "must prove the truth, that is, the reality and power, the this-sidedness of [Feuerbach's] thinking into practice. The dispute over the reality of non-reality of thinking which is isolated from practice is a purely scholastic question." Merrifield paraphrases: Philosophers can argue about truth until they are blue in the face. But they'll never find real truth in hallowed university debating rooms. Abstract thinking can be tested out only by being put through its paces, by making it right because it has been made to work.
Here on Discordia we had discussions about what it means to be "academic" (g-d forbid). I think there is no problem with theory unless it removes itself from everyday experiences. Then I'd use the a-word also.

[ --------------------------------------------- ]



Sort:
Display:
Book Review: Metromarxism by Andy Merrifield | 1 comments
[new] question: (Avg. Score: none / Raters: 0) (#1)
by amyalexander on Thu May 8th, 2003 at 04:40:31 PM EURODISCORDIA TIME
(User Info)

Let's grandfather Marx speak:

Now, humans "must prove the truth, that is, the reality and power, the this-sidedness of [Feuerbach's] thinking into practice. The dispute over the reality of non-reality of thinking which is isolated from practice is a purely scholastic question." Merrifield paraphrases: Philosophers can argue about truth until they are blue in the face. But they'll never find real truth in hallowed university debating rooms. Abstract thinking can be tested out only by being put through its paces, by making it right because it has been made to work.


question: how does that relate to the book? it's obviously marxist, but.. how did the metromarxist scholars discussed in the book relate to this issue? i'm guessing it has to do with the way they relate to the city? can you explain more about that?



 
Book Review: Metromarxism by Andy Merrifield | 1 comments
Menu

[- how to post and vote
[- faq (discordia q&a)
[- faq en español
[- search
[- send feedback

[- sick of english?
[- multi-lingual babelfilter

Login
[- Username
[- Password


Make new account >>

Stories, articles, images and comments are owned by the Author. The Rest © 2003 The Discordants under the Gnu Public License

submit story | create account | faq | search